Best mascara so far

looking for something not to heavy, but that also added a good amount of volume. doesn’t clump up like others do. i have a bad habit of rubbing my eyes (i know) and it hardly smudged – comparable to a waterproof mascara

One person found this helpful

Best Natural Mascara!

I love this stuff! It gives me VOLUME and stays on all day (unless I get teary eyed).

Great volume!

Great volume, makes lashes look great! Will definitely purchase again. Love this company and what they stand for as well.

Meh I’m on the fence

I LOVE how this mascara gives my lashes a boost and volume (it’s the best I’ve found in years that doesn’t really clump and the primer really helps your lashes fan out!) What I am bummed out about it’s durability — despite doing all of the tips and tricks to keep your mascara from “wilting” and giving you those dark smudges, after a couple (about 3-4) hours you are wiping the black smudges from under the outer corner of your eyes ??So id say it’s great for length and volume as well as minimal clumping or flaking but it gets a “fail” for smudging!

One person found this helpful

Will repurchase!

This is a great mascara regardless of whether you’re into clean beauty or not. Formula is somewhat dry which helps it build volume and hold a curl. Can get clumpy if you apply too many layers so be sure to keep a clean spoolie or eyelash comb around. I will definitely repurchase.

3 people found this helpful

Great Mascara

I LOVE this mascara! I have bought it five times now. It makes my lashes look amazing (long and full, separates them), and it lasts all day. I don’t have any problems with smudging or flaking. I can go to the chiropractor and lay face down, and when I get up, there is no mascara on the paper or around my eyes, and my lashes don’t stick together. This happened with a previous natural mascara. The only thing that disappoints me a little is that it starts to dry up after about a month. That is wearing it consistently for 5/6 days a week. I can make it last longer, but it just doesn’t have the same ease of application. I definitely recommend!

2 people found this helpful

Good Lengthening Mascara

I liked this mascara a lot. It is very easy to get tons of length, two-three coats gives me mile long lashes .The only thing I felt was less than satisfactory about this product, was I felt it stared to dry up after only a month of use. I liked the primer as well, when I used that before the mascara, my lashes were super long going over them once, but I used a second coating to get them more symmetrical. I would repurchase in the future, but probably get the mascara only option. I rarely use a lash primer. Typically I wear mascara, eye pencil/brow fill, and sometimes a tinted sunscreen. This mascara makes my lashes super long, but not at all caked in globs of mascara.It is a more natural looking product. The ingredients, are good, I like the product, and the final look.

10 people found this helpful

Loved this mascara

Was looking for a hypoallergenic mascara for my very sensitive eyes. This mascara was very impressive, did not irritate my eyes like other mascaras and really held the curl as my eyelashes are extremely straight

If you don’t wear falsies, this light mascara will keep your lashes lifted

I was trying to find an eco-friendly product that doesn’t test on animals for a while and stumbled across this one. I’ve been using it now for about two years and have named it my favorite mascara. I don’t use false lashes, so I need a mascara that will keep my lashes curled and looking long and full, which is exactly what this one does!! It adds so much length. I’ve been asked multiple times while wearing this mascara if my lashes are mine or not, haha.I love it and hope you will! I know everyone finds the product that works best for them, but I really think it’s worth giving this mascara a shot.

11 people found this helpful

My favorite

Literally the best mascara ever!! It lasts the whole day and is so easy to take off with some makeup remover and won’t ruin your eye lashes!

LOVE!!!

works well… ive had MAC mascaras that didnt give me as much length

Not Going to be For Everyone

I purchased this mascara because my eyes have become very sensitive over the past few years. I am a person that prefers volumizing mascaras. I HATED this on first and second use. If you are someone who prefers full, fluffy lashes, this may not be for you. This product will lengthen and separate UNLESS you really take the time to learn the product.However (!!!) It is a good product. I was pretty desperate for a non-irritating formula so I kept on using it and now I really love it! Just be prepared for a learning curve! If you are willing to learn the nuances of this product (primer and mascara) you could end up really enjoying it. If you are not willing to work to get your desired effect, I would pass. Especially if your eyes are not sensitive to other mascaras.

5 people found this helpful

Extreme Length mascara

I’m still on the fence about this mascara because it absolutely does what it says by making my lashes longer but.. the first day I used it one of my eyes started watering a lot and the mascara smudged when I was trying to wipe my eye. I tried it again a couple of days later and the watering was not as extreme but my eyes felt like they were on the verge of starting to water. I’m on day three of wearing it, this time to work and it’s not as bad but still feels like I have something in my eyes. I’m reserving judgment since my normal silver colored car is now has a yellow green shimmer to it from all the pollen in the air. As far as the mascara.. the length is noticeable and it definitely doesn’t add fullness.. so.. you have to decide which you want more.. and it’s NOT waterproof

2 people found this helpful

Inconsistent Fomula

I’ve been buying this product for a couple of years now. 75% of the time, the formula is great and provides magnifying volume to my lashes. However, recently the formula has been inconsistent. It’s hit or miss, and the misses cause my lashes to really clump and provide little to no volume. Ive even tried adding saline solution to see it this would remedy the clumping, but was unsuccessful. Not sure if I will continue purchasing this product due to this inconsistency, which is a shame as I would swear by this stuff prior!

4 people found this helpful

Great for sensitive eyes

So far, I have really enjoyed this product. It does clump some but I have not had any itchy or watery eyes like when I use other mascaras. Will definitely purchase again.

Works well enough

Does make lashes longer, but clumps a bit on me. Just have to separate my lashes after applying

Didn’t work for me

The primer part was very dry and didn’t work for me

Clumpy

Super clumpy mascara but definitely adds volume and length. Make sure to have another spoolie on hand to try and get the clumps out.

One person found this helpful

Love it! Read for advice on applying.

I was reluctant to get it because some of the review pictures looked so clumpy and others looked great. I’m glad I gave it a try because it’s wonderful. I have really long eyelashes due to years of applying castor oil to them but they’re very light brown so I need a good mascara to show them off. Since I like keeping my natural lashes healthy I don’t use waterproof stuff that’s hard to get off. This stuff is definitely not waterproof if that’s what you want but it doesn’t smear terribly. It does leave a little flaking throughout the day but nothing severe or difficult to wipe away.The picture doesn’t do justice because I could use a phone upgrade but I took it after applying one layer. You can apply a second layer without it clumping and it adds a decent amount of volume and length.ADVICE::: letting the primer completely dry before applying the mascara makes it more likely you’ll have clumps. If you do it right after the primer it goes on nice and smooth. Applying too much primer will also make it more problematic. Too much primer AND letting it dry all the way before applying mascara = a spider on your eye. It’s not cute. Also, this isn’t my favorite style of brush but I have found that I don’t get as much of it on my eyelid with the short bristles so that’s a win.

8 people found this helpful

Wanted to love

I do like the fact this mascara is “clean” & it did remove easily. The primer brush was barely applying the product & the amount of product barely covered my lashes. Not exactly sure what the issue seems to be. The mascara itself covered the brush but it went on uneven and gloppy.I believe this product needs some fine-tuning to be a better overall item that I would want to reorder.

It’s True: Longer, Thicker Lashes!

I sound like a commercial. Just received this mascara and tried it. Put just a little of the primer on, then mascara. Made my lashes look longer and also kept them from wanting to clump.

One person found this helpful

Lush lashes!

No need for fake lashes when you use this mascara! It definitely volumizes your lashes.

Love/Hate

This mascara is pretty impressive with its primer and mascara combo, the result does show a difference and creates a fuller look to the lashes which I love. But for anyone who doesn’t use a strong makeup remover and tends to just shower and wash everything off with soap and water this thing will not disappear easily. It tends to smear under the eyelid and leave darkness that then needs to be scrubbed off. At the beach this isn’t fun walking around with black eyes after swimming lol

15 people found this helpful

Not fiberwig but comes off easily

Good rating on my yuka app, so nice and clean ingredients. Gives natural fullness and doesn’t smudge but isn’t fiberwig… however comes off easily.

2 people found this helpful

Update: things got better. Old review: Was amazing until the formula was changed

Update:After a few months, the formula got drier and is now very similar to the original formula. The result is similar as well – lashes are thick and long. Still upset I have to wait a few months for the mascara to dry to get good results. I am going to let the new one dry by leaving it open for an hour… I wish they provided some sort of thickening powder for people who don’t like runny mascara. I have to admit that the old formula would get too dry after a few months and I had to use contact lens solution or water to dilute it.Old review:Loved it before. Would always get as a present for others. Now, thismascara is more liquid and the lashes are not as long or thick once you apply it. PLEASE LET US BUY THE OLD FORMULA.

One person found this helpful

This is GREAT Mascara!

I am really pleased with this mascara! It goes on well, has smooth coverage, does not smudge or clump. I put on several layers and each layer adds on nicely. I’ve applied it with the primer and without. It looks great either way; I definitely get more length with the primer.I’ve worn a variety of mascara brands from Revlon to Chanel. Honest extreme length mascara lash and lash primer is my new favorite. I do a lot of Zoom meetings and I can definitely tell a difference with this mascara.

7 people found this helpful

Lashes like Garbo

I think this might be my new go to mascara.I have the teeniest tiniest lashes ever, they are straight and stick out from my eyelids and without mascara I look like I have no lashes so it’s a struggle finding mascaras that make my lashes look lush.Let me start off by saying that the primer is amazing.As soon as I put it on my lashes grew over twice in length!It didn’t clump and separated my lashes like whoa( the clumping with these lash fiber or extra lengthening mascaras is always horrendous so that was a wonderful surprise), it dried in about 20 seconds and then I put on the coal black mascara.Vavoom ladies!Instant fabulous lashes.So far I have experienced zero flaking after wearing for long periods of time , it hasn’t smudged or melted when I’m dancing up a storm or getting my workout on and the length of my lashes is practically miraculous.It is not cry proof.It’s super easy to remove and doesn’t tear out any of my eyelashes though, so that’s another plus!Also, I have celiac disease and a host of other random allergies and am allergic to SO MANY products it’s ridiculous, but luckily I am not allergic to this magic mascara.I recently discovered that this doesn’t smudge on my bottom lashes either!I’m almost 40 and I have never found a mascara that didn’t smudge on my bottom lashes. I’m so oily that even waterproof ones didn’t work!I stopped wearing it on my bottom lashes for anything but photo shoots after 20yrs old because the smudging made me look like an old lady with terrible makeup skills,but now I can once again rock liner on my bottom lashes!I included a terrible picture ( I hate getting my picture taken!) and tried to crop it so you can get an idea of how amazing this mascara is( look at those lashes practically touching my brow bone!),because I know I always want to actually see the results of people using the product, so hopefully it helps. :-)Ps: I don’t have mascara on my bottom lashes in the pic as I didn’t discover it was even a possibility for me until I bought a tube for my bestie ( another oily faced queen)and she told me there was no smudging:-O

1,090 people found this helpful

Probably my favorite ever!

I love this mascara! My lashes look so long and voluminous! I think I’ll be a lifer with this one!

Nice product

I like it. It last until I remove it.

Great payoff and natural option, smudged a bit

Wear: Love the rich black of this mascara and it looks awesome on, but within 10 minutes of being outside in 96F heat wearing a mask, I got smudging under my eyes (not surprisingly, ha). It had also smudged inside before I went out, but more noticeable after being outside. If you don’t have an issue with mascara smudging then try this one out! I can only wear tubing mascara to avoid smudging, so this is an issue I deal with wearing ANY mascara other than the tube kind. I guess I have oilier eyes or it’s my lash length, who knows.Brush: not a big fan of the rubber, short bristles since they don’t fan out lashes very well, you have to be light-handed to not clump lashes together. If they change this brush, I think it would have better application, but oh well. I just did a couple swipes to avoid sticking lashes together. The brush on the primer is fine and although tiny, I think a bit better than the main brush.Primer: It’s fine and I think does help the formula “stick” to the lashes, but I’ll also try without it and see what I think. I found the little brush easy to use, it did coat my lashes well. Definitely wait the 30 seconds or more for it to dry otherwise the mascara will get too gummy going on. I think the combo added ok volume… I’m not looking for crazy volume, so this works for me. My lashes are already long so can’t really comment on length very well.Removal: Came off easily with warm water, but took some effort to not have it smudge onto my skin and I still had to use soap to remove the smudged formula on my skin, but there was no irritation during removal and soap and water was fine. I still prefer tubes, so easy to remove, but this was comparable if not easier to remove compared to other non waterproof formulas.Overall: I think this is a great natural formula. Not my fave natural (I love Lily Lolo for a natural, albeit not volumizing, formula), but I’m happy to wear this while working at home and the price is much better. I wanted something for everyday wear that is non-irritating and this works. For a non-natural, affordable formula, I love the L’Oreal Double Extend mascara… has a primer, good volume, and it’s tubing so no smudging at all. I did want a natural formula though, so I’ll be alternating these two formulas for the rest of the year!

3 people found this helpful